2020: F1 Discussions

Locked
Posts
6,047
Likes
7,292
Yes, a very dramatic start. Glad Grosjean is OK. Amazing he walked away from that seeing the wreckage of his car.
 
Posts
10,197
Likes
11,381
Thank God and the car's halo that Grosjean did not sustain major injuries in that horrific crash!

 
Posts
585
Likes
471
I didn't think anybody could survive that crash. Then Grosjean leaps out of the flames like the terminator. Incredible mental strength from Romain, incredible engineering ability from Haas and the world of F1. Never seen a fireball impact like that outside of the archives of the 60's and 70's.
Edited:
 
Posts
4,061
Likes
5,934
The car was literally split into two causing fuel to spill out and therfore the fire. Good to know that only minor burns were sustained after the crash. No fractures, no inhalational injuries etc. Props to the FIA / F1 safety and advancement in technology. A single life is much more than anything above the sport.

This might be an eye-opener to some after this horrific accident, now that Grosjean is a given a second-lease. I pray he recovers well and hopefully none like this happens again.
 
Posts
125
Likes
288
Unbelievable race. I thought Istanbul was good but Bahrain really changed the dynamics...

Who says auto racing isn’t perilous anymore.

M.
 
Posts
4,061
Likes
5,934
Also have to give credit to a double podium for Red Bull Racing & TAG Heuer 👍👍

Congratulations to Max & Alex! TAG Heuer ::rimshot::
 
Posts
22,061
Likes
31,210
Commiserations to Sergio who should have been 3rd and who should be driving for RB next year.
 
Posts
6,047
Likes
7,292
One thing I thought was slightly amusing was Grosjean being awarded "driver of the day". No doubt he was a winner in the sense of walking away from that terrible accident, but he did kind of cause the accident didn't he by swooping across the circuit?
 
Posts
4,061
Likes
5,934
Yes, it is unfortunate, with his aggressive right overtake. Kyvat was at the receiving end from this although he was at fault that caused a DNF for Stroll on another accident saved by the Halo again.

Probably for Grosjean, it’s about time to pause and take a break from Formula 1.
 
Posts
585
Likes
471
One thing I thought was slightly amusing was Grosjean being awarded "driver of the day". No doubt he was a winner in the sense of walking away from that terrible accident, but he did kind of cause the accident didn't he by swooping across the circuit?
They did indicate that some debris from Stroll's car may have hit Grosjean's. But it does look like Grosjean just made an unnecessarily aggressive change of direction, causing the collision with Kvyat, which pitched him into the wall. A simple driver error.
 
Posts
585
Likes
471
The car was literally split into two causing fuel to spill out and therfore the fire. Good to know that only minor burns were sustained after the crash. No fractures, no inhalational injuries etc. Props to the FIA / F1 safety and advancement in technology. A single life is much more than anything above the sport.

This might be an eye-opener to some after this horrific accident, now that Grosjean is a given a second-lease. I pray he recovers well and hopefully none like this happens again.
I don't think the drivers would agree at all. The danger and the risk is a component of the overall difficulty that makes race driving such an achievement. If it was safe and easy for anyone to do then there would be no achievement, and no reward to be earned. It's a spectacle to behold because it's such an impressive feat. Racing drivers brains work differently to that of Joe Public.

There's been lots of media focus on what didn't happen. And not enough on what did - that a man is safe and well. Partly due to good fortune, but thanks to a very large extent to human achievement. Which is the best possible outcome. The media likes to imagine worst case scenarios, to give it something to rage about and demonise in the name of 'social justice'. Even the BBC is running headlines that F1 has "soul-searching to do". No, it doesn't! Because, unlike the BBC, F1 has its shit together and is a professional organisation!

Sorry for rant 😀
 
Posts
22,061
Likes
31,210
I think it was one of those things. In hindsight was it a great idea to have the barrier at that angle to the track? No. If the barrier was parallel with the track Grosjean would have hit it hard but slid along and ripped the side off. Would anyone ever expect anyone to hit that barrier? No. Unless you put tecpro barriers everywhere there's always a possibility of an issue.
 
Posts
6,047
Likes
7,292
They did indicate that some debris from Stroll's car may have hit Grosjean's. But it does look like Grosjean just made an unnecessarily aggressive change of direction, causing the collision with Kvyat, which pitched him into the wall. A simple driver error.
Even if it wasn't his fault, it's still a bit of a stretch I think to award him driver of the day 😀
 
Posts
3,033
Likes
2,966
I think it was one of those things. In hindsight was it a great idea to have the barrier at that angle to the track? No. If the barrier was parallel with the track Grosjean would have hit it hard but slid along and ripped the side off. Would anyone ever expect anyone to hit that barrier? No. Unless you put tecpro barriers everywhere there's always a possibility of an issue.
I watched the highlights show today -only due the excitement- and the angle of the barrier was immediately in my thought, if not a head on an angled incident may have pitched a car back across the track creating more mayhem, so parallel or inclined the opposite direction been better, Shouldn’t the barrier been strong enough to withstand the hit without splitting and trapping the car. When working underground we installed barriers to catch runaway material loads, three were place in line astern increasing in strength to initially slow the load without a sudden stop, possibly an idea for Armco where space permits. Just glad to see Grosjean emerge from the flames with out any worse injuries than he suffered, wishing him a rapid recovery.
 
Posts
125
Likes
288
A relative newcomer to F1 =

Not sure Grosjean has the confidence and talent for world class competition.

Yes, Perez’s performance was exceptional, but the race is still about the team...and the car.

Alex Albon, new talent that very well may lay the cornerstone of the next generation. Glad to see him there.
 
Posts
4,061
Likes
5,934
I completely understand how different people see this incident in different perspectives. It’s good to discuss this because there are still ways to improve the situation.

I’d like to think of recent “near death experiences” of F1 drivers due to horrific crash but came out walking afterwards. Thanks to a big leap in safety advancements/technology after Senna’s death that became a catalyst and catapulted to what it is today.
1. Alonso’s air spin in Melbourne 2016 (No Halo)

2. Ericsson’s DRS malfunction crash in Monza 2018 (with Halo)


3. Leclerc & Alonso in Belgium 2018 (with Halo)


Formula 1 is a motor “sport” first and foremost than entertainment. The principles of “sports” like fairplay, adherence to rules etc are and should be inherent. Lives should be paramount more than anything else. No one needlessly die in sports. But these are risks athletes are willing to take. But again, these are also extreme circumstances with speeds more than 300km/h and always trying to defy what is the limit.