Very interesting story in the grey market seller, seems very dubious. I got the impression that grey market sellers were more an interface to buy from a number of ADs across a region (Europe, USA) rather than a single shop like then guys you talked to.
I presume that grey market dealers often buy what they can get their hands on and some probably dont look too carefully into the origin of the goods
It seems to me that their whole business model is by it's very nature 'shady'
So the reason grey dealers exist is because authorized dealers have quotas to buy from the manufacturer. Kind of like how you have to buy X number of diamond and gold Datejusts if you want a Daytona, if you want to be able to sell the in-demand models from TAG or Omega or whoever you need to buy and stock a number of the slower-selling watches. So dealers will often unload those at wholesale prices to grey dealers instead of having them take up valuable space in display cases or stockrooms where they’re most likely gonna sit for way too long
So the reason grey dealers exist is because authorized dealers have quotas to buy from the manufacturer. Kind of like how you have to buy X number of diamond and gold Datejusts if you want a Daytona, if you want to be able to sell the in-demand models from TAG or Omega or whoever you need to buy and stock a number of the slower-selling watches. So dealers will often unload those at wholesale prices to grey dealers instead of having them take up valuable space in display cases or stockrooms where they’re most likely gonna sit for way too long
the manufacturers themselves are actively pushing stock into the grey market
They probably sell current stock to the AD for x and can sell for the same price to the Grey’s. AD’s sell for full price and profit
I'm sure there are reputable 'grey' dealers, but how is the public supposed to know which ones are reputable and which ones are willing to take 'unwanted stock' from other sources. The problem is that surely they would sell to each other too, so there must be endless opportunities to introduce rogue stock. Especially since they all use the get out that your watch doesn't have the manufacturer's warranty but we will give you our warranty. So you send it back to them, what are the chances it actually goes back to TAG Heuer? Most likely they have a 'guy' who can fix most things with no questions asked. It sucks for the honest ones, but I would tend to err on the side of guilty til proven innocent.