Design Concepts

Posts
890
Likes
1,375
Of course! What else can you expect from haters? 馃榿
That's OK, Speedy Tuesday reminds me of Speedy Autavia 2446.
 
Posts
4,257
Likes
7,186
Yes, the Omega Tintin reminds one of the three versions of the Carrera Racing by @Ara ... and for me this Carrera R (even when I put it in 3rd position of the three Ara designs) is the clear winner 馃憤

It鈥檚 a bit similar but even in concept stage it looks a lot better than the Speedy. The racing box has chequered squares iso rectangles so it could be tweeked to move it away from the Speedy. Some finetuning by Ara would make this a bomb. Which vintage Heuer Carrera enthusiast wouldn鈥檛 want this one? I鈥檓 certain it would sell out. I鈥檓 keeping a spot warm.

 
Posts
11,967
Likes
39,426
Ara Ara
Just tell them it's actually ripped off our own Red Racing Box from 1969

Yeah but... it isn't though

It was actually inspired by the Tintin moon rocket, as seen in the post above ^ . Herge's estate (IP holders of the Tintin trademarks) didn't agree to license it though which is why they called it "racing" or some such.

EDIT: oh you mean your Carrera. Of course, but even so it does bear a very close resemblance. No matter - see if you can get Bamford to agree to it! (We have not seen the last of the Glassbox so there will still be cases manufactured...)
 
Posts
4,257
Likes
7,186
The Red Racing Carrera might also look good in the 41mm elegant case.
 
Posts
6,031
Likes
16,443
The racing box has chequered squares iso rectangles so it could be tweeked to move it away from the Speedy

So do you mean like this, using squares (exactly like the box) instead of rectangles?

 
Posts
890
Likes
1,375
So do you mean like this, using squares (exactly like the box) instead of rectangles?

Well hello there. That looks great!
 
Posts
4,257
Likes
7,186
That鈥檚 nice, I like the squares more. Now I really want one 馃槈
A tad smaller subdials and it鈥檚 a slam dunk.
The double grain BoR would be a nice plus. The Auatavia bracelet is 21mm at the lugs so won鈥檛 fit unfortunately.
 
Posts
8,811
Likes
17,930
It鈥檚 a bit similar but even in concept stage it looks a lot better than the Speedy. The racing box has chequered squares iso rectangles so it could be tweeked to move it away from the Speedy. Some finetuning by Ara would make this a bomb. Which vintage Heuer Carrera enthusiast wouldn鈥檛 want this one? I鈥檓 certain it would sell out. I鈥檓 keeping a spot warm.

Do you own a Tintin? That Carrera around the Tintin rocket looks out of place. Seems like your model diorama is staged for a Tintin or at least some kind of Speedy.
 
Posts
4,257
Likes
7,186
I'm a Tintin fan but not that much of a Speedy fan. I think Tintin would opt for a classic 3 hander himself. Had a Speedy mark II and debated over a few others but there's always a watch that comes in between.
 
Posts
6,031
Likes
16,443
Ara Ara
Squared up the renders for you, @Albert-AMG. Also added a "Night" version in PVD just because.
Really nice!! 馃グ

My favourite strap for this Carrera Racing (for all three versions) is the perforated rally style with red stitching 馃憤
 
Posts
890
Likes
1,375
Really nice!! 馃グ

My favourite strap for this Carrera Racing (for all three versions) is the perforated rally style with red stitching 馃憤
Me too.
 
Posts
11,967
Likes
39,426
The Red Racing Carrera might also look good in the 41mm elegant case.

I had the same idea at the beginning of the weekend, put a rough one together.

 
Posts
11,967
Likes
39,426
The racing box has chequered squares iso rectangles so it could be tweeked to move it away from the Speedy.

A word about squares versus rectangles: The racing dial uses rectangles that match the intervals of the seconds, so that the chrono needle can be immediately followed as it sweeps past each tick. Thus, my render matches the scale, and my vote is that the rectangles stay
 
Posts
6,031
Likes
16,443
I agree with @Yago about using squares and not rectangles, as this design is inspired by the Heuer boxes, so the squares have a more direct Heuer link, and also with the racing checkered flag... and also moving it away from the Tintin Omega



I already have the three new versions for the TH Connected 馃槈
 
Posts
11,967
Likes
39,426
I agree with @Yago about using squares and not rectangles, as this design is inspired by the Heuer boxes, so the squares have a more direct Heuer link, and also with the racing checkered flag... and also moving it away from the Tintin Omega

... and also making it very difficult to read the chronograph. Thus moving us even further away from the central design ethos of the Carrera
 
Posts
6,031
Likes
16,443
... and also making it very difficult to read the chronograph. Thus moving us even further away from the central design ethos of the Carrera
We have the scale on the red outer ring. I see no problem at all to read the chronograph. Your idea about the rectangles matching the seconds would be nice for a quartz chronograph, but I don鈥檛 see it useful for an automatic watch, when we have a much more clear and precise scale on the outer ring

This is a version with rectangles matching the seconds. To read the chronograph, are you looking at the outer ring scale, or are you counting rectangles?
Edited:
 
Posts
11,967
Likes
39,426
Your idea about the rectangles matching the seconds would be nice for a quartz chronograph, but I don鈥檛 see it useful for an automatic watch, when we have a much more clear and precise scale on the outer ring

I'm sorry, I don't follow why it would work for quartz but not automatic.

This is a version with rectangles matching the seconds. To read the chronograph, are you looking at the outer ring scale, or are you counting rectangles?

You see, the idea of the racing dial is not whether or not it matches the track - it's intended for higher contrast so that it makes reading the chronograph very easy even at speed:

28_20151202170919_3859026_large.jpg

The Tintin iterated on this but had the hash marks in each bloc:

omega-speedmaster-professional-moonwatch-311-30-42-30-01-004-119.jpg

Racing tracks on chronographs were not intended simply to look nice - this was an innovation with a purpose. And since the heritage of Heuer is most strongly associated with racing, I think we should use the checkered-flag motif in service of that.
 
Posts
4,257
Likes
7,186
These are good points. I like the idea of using the chequers for easy reading of the chronograph seconds iso just aesthetics. Having both won鈥檛 be possible as we鈥檚 end up with huge squares. A nod to the boxes but with rectangles works. So back to the original design. But I鈥檓 glad we鈥檙e having the discussion. 馃榾